Inspection Findings:
Based on observation, interview and record review the facility failed to provide sufficient nursing staff to ensure residents attained or maintained their highest practicable mental, physical, and psychosocial well-being for 4 of 7 sampled residents (#s 1, 2, 3, and 13) and 2 of 2 floors reviewed for call light wait times and staffing. This placed residents at risk for lack of ADL care needs. Findings include:
1. Resident 1 was admitted to the facility in 2015 with diagnoses including diabetes, and renal disease.
A care plan dated 9/5/23, and revised on 12/5/24, revealed Resident 1 was incontinent of bowel and bladder. Resident 1 required one or two-person assistance for all ADL care needs and required a mechanical lift for transfers.
On 12/27/24 at 1:30 PM, Witness 20 (Complainant) stated Resident 1 had concerns regarding long call light response times, which were 30 minutes or longer. Witness 20 stated the resident called him on multiple occasions when she/he was sitting in a wet and soiled brief. Witness 20 stated ongoing concerns with staffing and long call light response times dated back to July 2024.
On 12/30/24 at 12:32 PM, Staff 12 (CNA) and at 3:35 PM, Staff 13 (CNA) stated the resident was dependent on ADL care needs and had concerns with not enough staff to answer call lights. Staff 12 stated Resident 1 sat in wet and soiled briefs for 20 minutes or longer on more than one occasion.
On 12/30/24 at 3:53 PM, Resident 1 was observed in bed. Resident 1 stated the facility did not have enough CNAs, which was a concern since the beginning of summer and continued to be an issue. Resident 1 stated call lights were long, at times up to 30 plus minutes. Resident 1 further stated she/he sat in a wet and soiled brief on multiple occasions.
On 1/6/25 at 1:48 PM, Staff 11 (LPN-Resident Care Manager) stated Resident 1 had concerns of long call light wait times, since the summer months and was due to being short staffed.
On 1/6/25 at 5:22 PM, Staff 1 (Administrator) and Staff 2 (DNS) stated they were aware of call lights being a concern and it was an ongoing issue. Staff 1 and Staff 2 stated all staff were responsible for answering call lights in a timely manner. Staff 1 and Staff 2 acknowledged the facility struggled with appropriate CNA staffing ratios.
2. Resident 2 was admitted to the facility in 2024 with diagnoses including a stroke and depression.
A care plan dated 6/28/24, and revised on 7/13/24, revealed Resident 2 was on a toileting program due to mixed bowel and bladder incontinence. Resident 2 required one-person assistance for all ADL care needs.
On 12/27/24 at 12:30 PM, Resident 2 indicated she/he needed assistance with toileting due to her/his left sided weakness. Resident 2 stated there were concerns with long call light response times and she/he had sat in a wet and soiled brief for 20 plus minutes once when she/he was first admitted and another episode towards the beginning of December 2024. Resident 2 stated long call light wait times were 20 to 30 plus minutes and was an ongoing concern.
On 12/30/24 at 12:32 PM, Staff 12 (CNA) and on 12/31/24 at 2:13 PM, Staff 16 (CNA) stated Resident 2 required assistance with toileting but at times soiled herself/himself because of long call light response times. Staff 12 and Staff 16 stated long call light response times and being short staffed were an ongoing concern.
On 12/31/24 at 9:45 AM, Staff 9 (LPN) stated Resident 2 concerns regarding long call light response times and had wet herself/himself on more than one occasion. Staff 9 stated the long call light response times were due to lack of staff which was an ongoing concern.
On 1/6/25 at 5:22 PM Staff 1 (Administrator) and Staff 2 (DNS) stated they were aware of call lights being a concern and it was an ongoing issue. Staff 1 and Staff 2 stated all staff were responsible for answering call lights in a timely manner. Staff 1 and Staff 2 acknowledged the facility struggled with appropriate CNA staffing ratios.
3. Resident 3 was admitted to the facility in 2020 with diagnoses including morbid obesity and depression.
A care plan dated 2/1/20, revealed Resident 3 was independent with transferring herself/himself in the room, utilized a bed side commode, and required one-person assistance with toileting hygiene.
On 12/27/24 at 10:44 AM, and 1/2/25 at 11:20 AM, Resident 3 was observed sitting on the edge of her/his bed, well groomed. Resident 3 stated there were ongoing concerns with long call light wait times and the facility was short staffed from July 2024 to present. Resident 3 stated she/he could get onto the bedside commode herself/himself but needed assistance with wiping. Resident 3 stated she/he sat on the bedside commode for greater than 20 minutes to almost an hour without assistance, which occurred on more than one occasion and was very frustrating.
On 12/30/24 from 11:00 AM, through 3:01 PM, Staff 22 (CNA), Staff 12 (CNA), and Staff 43 (CNA) were interviewed and stated Resident 3 needed assistance with wiping after she/he was on the bedside commode. Staff 22, Staff 12, and Staff 43 stated the resident sat on her/he bedside commode on multiple occasions for greater than 30 minutes. Staff 43 stated Resident 3 was frustrated and upset on those occasions because the bedside commode was uncomfortable.
On 1/6/25 at 2:11 PM, Staff 11 (LPN-Resident Care Manager) stated he was aware Resident 3 had concerns with long call light wait times and sat on her/his bedside commode for extended periods of time due to being short staffed. Staff 11 stated call lights and staffing was an ongoing issue.
On 1/6/25 at 5:22 PM, Staff 1 (Administrator) and Staff 2 (DNS) stated they were aware of call lights being a concern and it was an ongoing issue. Staff 1 and Staff 2 stated all staff were responsible for answering call lights in a timely manner. Staff 1 and Staff 2 acknowledged the facility struggled with appropriate CNA staffing ratios.
4. Resident 13 was admitted to the facility in 2021 with diagnoses including a stroke and anxiety.
A care plan dated 3/10/21, and revised on 12/5/24, revealed Resident 13 was frequently incontinent of urine. Staff were to assist Resident 13 with incontinent care after each episode. Resident 13 required substantial/maximum to dependent assistance with toileting hygiene.
On 12/30/24 at 10:57 AM, and 1/2/25 at 12:30 PM, Resident 13 stated call light response times were terrible, CNAs passed by her/his room without answering the call lights, and took upwards of 40 minutes or longer. Resident 13 stated she/he sat in a wet brief on more than one occasion. Resident 13 stated every shift was terrible, but weekends were the worst.
On 12/31/24 at 2:13 PM, Staff 16 (CNA) and on 1/3/25 at 2:13 PM, Staff 28 (CNA) were interviewed. Staff 16 and Staff 28 stated Resident 13 reported concerns with sitting in wet briefs on multiple occasions due to long call light response times of 20 to 30 minutes. Staff 16 and Staff 28 stated the resident was upset because it occurred on all shifts, but especially on the weekends.
On 1/6/25 at 5:22 PM Staff 1 (Administrator) and Staff 2 (DNS) stated they were aware of call lights being a concern and it was an ongoing issue. Staff 1 and Staff 2 stated all staff were responsible for answering call lights in a timely manner. Staff 1 and Staff 2 acknowledged the facility struggled with appropriate CNA staffing ratios.
5. A review of the Direct Care Staff Daily Reports from 7/4/24 through 1/1/25 revealed state minimum bariatric CNA staffing requirements were not maintained for 74 of 90 days reviewed for staffing.
On 12/27/24 the facility provided lists of residents who:
-Required assistance with eating and were considered an aspiration risk: 13
-Required two-person assistance with transfers or mechanical lift: 35
-Required assistance with toileting: 41
-Residents who were incontinent: 52
-Residents who required behavioral healthcare needs: 9
-Residents who required bariatric healthcare needs: 10
Review of Resident Council Notes revealed the following concerns from 6/2024 through 12/2024:
June 2024: Call lights were too long on evening shift.
July 2024: Call lights response times were horrible especially on weekends.
August 2024: Not enough staff on the weekends "so terrible." Call light response times up to an hour wait.
September 2024: Call light response time on swing shift were on average 30 to 45 minutes.
October 2024: Call light response time on evening shift were 40 plus minutes. Resident 3 utilized call light for assistance off her/his bedside commode and just waits because no CNAs come to assist her/him.
November 2024: Long call light response times on evening and swing shift. Residents called out for CNAs and they walked by the room and ignored the residents' call lights.
December 2024: Long call lights on evening shift and a resident waited 80 minutes for assistance. CNAs made excuses as to why they were unable to answer call lights timely. Showers were not completed at the scheduled time.
Interviews with staff revealed the following:
On 12/27/24 at 9:41 AM, Staff 23 (CNA) and at 11:00 AM, Staff 22 (CNA) both stated staffing was terrible. The facility was short staffed all the time since 7/2024 and continued to be a struggle. Staff 22 and Staff 23 stated call lights could be 45 minutes or longer, and residents sat in wet and soiled briefs on multiple occasions. Staff 22 and Staff 23 further stated there was high acuity residents, including bariatric residents, which took more time. Staff 23 and Staff 22 stated wet wipe and briefs were difficult to access, because those supplies were no longer stored in the linen closets and had to be requested and turned into Staff 2 (DNS), which took time away from resident care.
On 12/30/24 at 12:32 PM, Staff 12 (CNA) and at 2:20 PM, Staff 21 (CNA), and at 3:35 PM, Staff 48 (CNA) were interviewed. Staff stated they worked on both floors and staffing was not great. Staff 12, Staff 21 and Staff 48 stated the facility was short staffed constantly, as far back as 7/2024 and continued to be short staffed. Both floors had high acuity residents, as well as bariatric residents. Staff 12, Staff 21 and Staff 48 stated residents complained constantly regarding long call light response times, which ranged from 30 to 40 minutes, and residents sat in wet and soiled briefs due to lack of staffing. Staff 12, Staff 21 and Staff 48 stated the linen closets no longer had wet wipes or briefs and they had to request for additional wet wipes when running low or out and request more briefs, which at times made it difficult to provide timely care because CNAs had to turn in a form to Staff 2 (DNS) to receive the supplies, which resulted in longer call light wait times. Staff 12, Staff 21, and Staff 48 stated at times it was difficult to assist with getting residents up timely for meals and showers. Staff 12, Staff 21 and Staff 48 stated the facility was constantly short staffed, management was aware, and weekends were awful.
On 12/31/24 at 9:45 AM Witness 23 (Complainant) stated the facility was constantly short staff dating back to 7/2024 and continued struggling to meet the acuity of residents in the building. Witness 23 stated call lights were greater than 25 to 30 minutes at times, depending on how short staffed the facility was. Witness 23 stated residents were very upset regarding lack of care and sitting in soiled briefs. Staff 23 further stated CNAs had to request wet wipes and brief supplies which slowed staff down because CNAs were to turn in a form to Staff 2 before acquiring more wet wipes or briefs. If Staff 2 was not available, the nursing staff had to access the supply room to retrieve more briefs for residents which took away from resident care.
On 12/31/24 at 2:13 PM, Staff 16 (CNA) stated he worked on both floors and the lack of staffing went back to during the summer months, and was ongoing. Staff 16 stated the facility was constantly short staffed and call light response times were 15 minutes on a good day. Staff 16 stated residents complained of sitting in wet and soiled briefs and were very upset about lack of staff. Staff 16 stated the summer months were worse.
On 1/2/25 at 10:00 AM, Staff 6 (RN) stated the facility struggled with staffing since 7/2024 and it was an ongoing concern. Staff 6 stated call light response times were long, and residents were very upset regarding call light response times. Staff 6 indicated it was difficult for her at times with CNAs not having access to wet wipes or briefs. If a CNA ran out of wet wipes and briefs, they completed a form and turned the form into Staff 2, to receive more supplies. If Staff 2 was not available, she would be responsible to retrieve more briefs from central supply for CNAs, which took time away from her resident care. Staff 6 stated she had never experienced anything like this.
On 1/2/25 at 2:03 PM, Staff 19 (CNA) stated being short staffed and long call light response times were an ongoing issue as far back as 7/2024. Staff 19 stated residents sat in wet and soiled briefs for 30 minutes or longer due to being short staffed. Staff 19 stated many residents required two-person assistance or were dependent on ADL care. Staff 19 further stated residents were very upset regarding lack of care being provided. Staff 19 stated management was aware but it continued to be an issue.
On 1/6/25 at 5:22 PM, Staff 1 (Administrator) and Staff 2 (DNS) stated they were aware CNA staffing shortages dating back to 7/2024 and they continued to work on hiring more CNAs and meeting the appropriate ratios. Staff 1 and Staff 2 acknowledged there were concerns regarding call light response times. Staff 1 and Staff 2 stated all staff were responsible for answering call lights in a timely manner.