Evidence/Findings:
Based on documentation review, record review, and interview, the governing authority failed to ensure compliance with Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) \'a7 36-411, for five of nine employee records reviewed.
Findings include:
1. A.R.S. \'a7 36-411 states:
"A. Except as provided in subsection F of this section, as a condition of licensure or continued licensure of a residential care institution, a nursing care institution or a home health agency and as a condition of employment in a residential care institution, a nursing care institution or a home health agency, employees and owners of residential care institutions, nursing care institutions or home health agencies, contracted persons of residential care institutions, nursing care institutions or home health agencies or volunteers of residential care institutions, nursing care institutions or home health agencies who provide medical services, nursing services, behavioral health services, health-related services, home health services or direct supportive services and who have not been subject to the fingerprinting requirements of a health professional's regulatory board pursuant to title 32 shall have valid fingerprint clearance cards that are issued pursuant to title 41, chapter 12, article 3.1 or shall apply for a fingerprint clearance card within twenty working days of employment or beginning volunteer work or contracted work.
B. A health professional who has complied with the fingerprinting requirements of the health professional's regulatory board as a condition of licensure or certification pursuant to title 32 is not required to submit an additional set of fingerprints to the department of public safety pursuant to this section.
C. Owners shall make documented, good faith efforts to:
1. Contact previous employers to obtain information or recommendations that may be relevant to a person's fitness to work in a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency.
2. Verify the current status of a person's fingerprint clearance card.
D. An employee, an owner, a contracted person or a volunteer or a facility on behalf of the employee, the owner, the contracted person or the volunteer shall submit a completed application that is provided by the department of public safety within twenty days after the date the person begins work or volunteer service.
E. Except as provided in subsection F of this section, a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency shall not allow an employee to continue employment or a volunteer or contracted person to continue to provide medical services, nursing services, behavioral health services, health-related services, home health services or direct supportive services if the person has been denied a fingerprint clearance card pursuant to title 41, chapter 12, article 3.1, has been denied approval pursuant to this section before May 7, 2001 or has had a fingerprint clearance card suspended or revoked.
F. An employee, volunteer or contractor of a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency who is eligible pursuant to section 41-1758.07, subsection C to petition the board of fingerprinting for a good cause exception and who provides documentation of having applied for a good cause exception pursuant to section 41-619.55 but who has not yet received a decision is exempt from the fingerprinting requirements of this section if the person provides medical services, nursing services, behavioral health services, health-related services, home health services or direct supportive services to residents or patients while under the direct visual supervision of an owner or employee who has a valid fingerprint clearance card.
G. If a person's employment record contains a six-month or longer time frame during which the person was not employed by any employer, a completed application with a new set of fingerprints shall be submitted to the department of public safety.
H. For the purposes of this section:
1. "Direct supportive services":
(a) Means services other than home health services that provide direct individual care and that are not provided in a common area of a health care institution, including:
(i) Assistance with ambulating, bathing, toileting, grooming, eating and getting in and out of a bed or chair.
(ii) Assistance with self-administration of medication.
(iii) Janitorial, maintenance, housekeeping or other services provided in a resident's room.
(iv) Transportation services, including van services.
(b) Does not include services provided by persons contracted directly by a resident or the resident's family in a health care institution.
2. "Direct visual supervision" means continuous visual oversight of the supervised person that does not require the supervisor to be in a superior organizational role to the person being supervised.
3. "Home health services" has the same meaning prescribed in section 36-151."
2. A review of E2's personnel record revealed no documentation of good faith efforts made to contact previous employers to obtain information or recommendations that may be relevant to a person's fitness to work in a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency.
3. A review of E3's personnel record revealed no documentation of good faith efforts made to contact previous employers to obtain information or recommendations that may be relevant to a person's fitness to work in a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency.
4. A review of E3's Personnel record also revealed a copy of a fingerprint clearance card issued on February 6, 2018, though there was no documentation to confirm the card was verified through the Department of Public Safety. A review of the status on the DPS website revealed the status of "Invalid". The website also revealed another application was received by DPS, on April 9, 2022, with a status listed as "Application complete - Results mailed to applicant".
5. A review of E4's personnel record revealed no documentation of good faith efforts made to contact previous employers to obtain information or recommendations that may be relevant to a person's fitness to work in a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency.
6. A review of E7's personnel record revealed no documentation of reference checks, a fingerprint clearance card, or an application for a fingerprint clearance card. personnel record revealed no documentation of good faith efforts made to contact previous employers to obtain information or recommendations that may be relevant to a person's fitness to work in a residential care institution, nursing care institution or home health agency.
7. A review of E8's personnel record revealed no evidence of a fingerprint clearance card or an application of a fingerprint clearance card.
8. In an interview, E1 reported E8 wasn't actually an employee but a family member. A review of E8's personnel record revealed a hire date in 2018 and a review of a posted designation of management for 2022 revealed E8 to be a designee.
9. In an interview, E1 acknowledged the personnel records provided for E2, E3, E4, E7, and E8 did not include documentation of compliance with A.R.S. \'a7 36-411.
Summary:
The following deficiencies were found during the on-site compliance inspection and investigation of complaint 00143296 and 00142355 conducted on September 8, 2025: