Evidence/Findings:
Based on documentation review, record review and interview, the manager failed to ensure a caregiver provided documentation of completion of a caregiver training program approved by the Department or the Board of Examiners for Nursing Care Institution Administrators and Assisted Living Facility Managers (NCIA), for three of nine individuals sampled who were hired as a caregiver. The deficient practice posed a risk if E5, E7, and E8 were not qualified to provide the required services.
Findings include:
1. A review of the facility's policies and procedures revealed a policy titled, "Licensing of Nursing Personnel," dated June 8, 2021. Under the title, "Procedure," the document stated: "1. At the time of employment, nursing personnel who require a license or registration present verification of such license to the Resident Services Director and/or to Human Resources. 2. A copy of the current license and registration number is filed in the nurse's personnel record...4. If the validity or standing of a license is in question, the Resident Services Director and/or Human Resources will contact the appropriate board for verification. 5. Until the license is verified, the nurse will not perform any duties requiring licensure."
2. A review of E5's personnel record (hired as a caregiver) revealed a document titled, "Community Living Services, Inc. Part I Training Transcript for [E5]" located in Wayne, Michigan. The document indicated, "Training Complete for Part I Group Home Training Program. Date Completed: August 13, 2002."
3. A review of E5's personnel record revealed a training transcript from Macomb-Oakland Regional Center, Inc., indicating training dates of November 26, 2007 and December 11, 2007. An Internet search revealed the Macomb-Oakland Regional Center was located in Michigan.
4. Further review of E5's personnel record revealed no evidence that indicated E5 completed a caregiver training program approved by the Department or the Board of Examiners for Nursing Care Institution Administrators and Assisted Living Facility Managers.
5. A review of the NCIA verification of caregiver training portal (https://az.tmuniverse.com/) revealed E5 had not completed a caregiver training program after August 3, 2013 in Arizona.
6. A review of E7's personnel record (hired as a medication technician/caregiver) revealed a caregiver training certificate from Red Mountain Senior Services, ALTP 00049, dated February 27, 2006. A review of the certificate revealed the ALTP number on the certificate was five digits, rather than the typical four digits. Further review revealed a misspelling of the word Completion in the title, (spelled "COMPLEATION") and mistakes in documentation of the certificate number and the "Restricted Use for only RMSH only till" date. Two numbers appeared altered as evidenced by two hand-written numbers being written over existing documentation and not initialed or dated to indicate the mistake.
7. A review of the NCIA verification of caregiver training portal (https://az.tmuniverse.com/) revealed E7 had not completed a caregiver training program after August 3, 2013.
8. A review of E8's personnel record (hired as a caregiver) revealed a caregiver training certificate from Adult Caregiver Training Institute, ALTP 0136, dated October 11, 2012. Further review of the certificate revealed the certificate did not indicate the correct number of training hours required for each level of care.
9. A review of the NCIA verification of caregiver training portal (https://az.tmuniverse.com/) revealed E8 had not completed a caregiver training program after August 3, 2013.
10. In an interview, E1 acknowledged the aforementioned personnel members appeared to have invalid caregiver certificates. E1 reported E5, E7, and E8 did not work alone at the facility.
Summary:
The following deficiencies were found during the on-site investigation of Case IDs 00121881 and 00132145 conducted on May 30, 2025: