Rule/Regulation Violated:
C. A manager shall ensure that a personnel record for each employee or volunteer:
1. Includes:
a. The individual's name, date of birth, and contact telephone number;
b. The individual's starting date of employment or volunteer service and, if applicable, the ending date; and
c. Documentation of:
i. The individual's qualifications, including skills and knowledge applicable to the individual's job duties;
ii. The individual's education and experience applicable to the individual's job duties;
iii. The individual's completed orientation and in-service education required by policies and procedures;
iv. The individual's license or certification, if the individual is required to be licensed or certified in this Article or in policies and procedures;
v. If the individual is a behavioral health technician, clinical oversight required in R9-10-115;
vi. Evidence of freedom from infectious tuberculosis, if required for the individual according to subsection (A)(8);
vii. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation training, if required for the individual in this Article or policies and procedures;
viii First aid training, if required for the individual in this Article or policies and procedures; and
ix. Documentation of compliance with the requirements in A.R.S. ยง 36-411(A) and (C);
Evidence/Findings:
Based on observation, interview, documentation review, and record review, the manager failed to ensure a personnel record was established and maintained for each employee as required. The deficient practice posed a risk as required information could not be verified for E1 and E2.
Findings include:
1. When the Compliance Officers arrived at the facility, E1 and E2 were observed at the facility.
2. In an interview, E1 and E2 were hired as caregivers identifying May 2, 2024, as their first day of work at AL10123.
3. A review of the facility's policies and procedures signed February 15, 2024, revealed a policy titled "Qualifications Caregivers, Assistant Caregiver and Volunteers." The policy stated "5) A manager shall ensure that a personnel record for a personnel member, employee, volunteer, or student include: full name, date of birth, current address and phone number, date of hire, work experience and references..." An additional policy titled "Orientation and in-service training" stated "New employee orientation is required to be completed by all new employees before starting to provide assisted living services to the residents..."
4. A review of E1's personnel file revealed no documentation of E1's date of employment, contact telephone number, verification of skills and knowledge, orientation, work experience and references.
5. A review of E2's personnel file revealed no documentation of E2's date of employment, contact telephone number, verification of skills and knowledge, orientation, work experience and references.
6. In an interview, E7 reviewed E1 and E2's personnel record. E1 acknowledged the identified documents were missing from E1 and E2's personnel record for AL10123.
7. In an interview, E2 reported E4 provided E2 orientation to the facility the previous day. However no documentation of the orientation was available for review.
8. In a phone interview, E3 acknowledged personnel records were not fully established for E1 and E2.
Summary:
The following deficiencies were found during the on-site compliance inspection conducted on May 2, 2024: